How to return the Plush Lynx, Tarnished Compass, and other Hallowfall mementos in World of Warcraft: The War Within

During your Quests with Maera Ashyld in World of Warcraft: The War Within, you’ll be given lost Hallowfall mementos, such as the Plush Lynx and Calcified Journal, which need to be returned to their owner. This guide covers how to obtain each lost memento and reunite them with their owner to earn the Lost and Found Achievement.

How to get Hallowfall mementos and return them to their owners in WoW: The War Within

The lost Hallowfall mementos are gained through Memories of the Sky questline, started by talking to Maera Ashlyd near Tenrir’s Ascent in Hallowfall (60.47, 60.16). Completing the questline will award you with the first three momentos: Plush Lynx, Tarnished Compass, and Broken Bracelet.

Returning to Maera the following week will unlock a second quest, Time Found, which gives you another three Momentos. After another week has passed, Maera will offer a final quest with the remaining momentos.

As of the time of publishing, only the first six lost Hallowfall momentos are currently available. It appears that a new quest becomes available every week.

All lost Hallowfall momento owner locations – Lost and Found Achievement guide

Before we begin, I highly recommend downloading the TomTom AddOn to make this Achievement as easy as possible. Simply copy and paste the respective command, and a handy arrow will show you the exact location. Don’t worry; I’ve also included map locations for every Momento hand-in location below.

• /way #2215 43.29 55.44 Plush Lynx
• /way #2215 43.46 51.69 Tarnished Compass
• /way #2215 65.44 32.25 Broken Bracelet
• /way #2215 43.69 49.71 Filigreed Cleric
• /way #2215 42.35 55.00 Dented Spearhead
• /way #2215 41.64 34.75 Ivory Tinderbox
• /way #2215 48 38 Calcified Journal
• /way #2215 69 43 Wooden Figure
• /way #2215 42 49 Sturdy Locket

Credit to Glandur for providing some of these coordinates.

Where to return the Plush Lynx

/way #2215 43.29 55.44 Phillip Taversil

Talk to Phillip Taversil in Mereldar and accept Stuffed Lynx Toy to return his Plush Lynx, Mr. Skinny.

Where to return the Tarnished Compass

/way #2215 43.46 51.69 Gravestone

Visit the large gravestone in Mereldar and accept Tarnished Compass to place it back where it belongs.

Where to return the Broken Bracelet

/way #2215 65.44 32.25 Keyrra Flamestonge

Find Keyrra Flamestonge in Fungal Fields and accept Broken Bracelet to return her sister’s memento.

Where to return the Filigreed Cleric

/way #2215 43.69 49.71 Kiera Horth

The Filigreed Cleric, Dented Spearhead, and Ivory Tinderbox become available from Maera Ashlyd at the next weekly reset. Accept Filligreed Cleric from Kiera Horth to hand it in.

Where to return the Dented Spearhead

/way #2215 42.35 55.00 Auralia Steelstrike

Accept Dented Spearhead from Auralia Steelstrike in the center of Mereldar to return this momento.

Where to return the Ivory Tinderbox

/way #2215 41.64 34.75 Haverd Sunhart

Accept Ivory Tinderbox from Haverd Sunhart at the entrance to the Priory of the Sacred Flame to hand it in.

Where to return the Calcified Journal

/way #2215 48.4 38.8 Lorel Ironglen

Talk to Lorel Ironglen at Lorel’s Crossing flight point to accept Calcified Journal and hand it in.

Where to return the Wooden Figure

/way #2215 59 43 Barahl Lynflayme

Pay Barahl Lynflayme a visit to accept Wooden Figure in Dunelle’s Kindness to return it to him.

Where to return the Sturdy Locket

The final lost Hallowfall momento can be handed in by accepting Sturdy Locket from Amy Lychenstone in Mereldar. Unlike the other NPCs, she paces around the town.

What is the reward for returning every lost Hallowfall momento?

Once all nine lost Hallowfall momentos found with Maera Ashlyd have been returned to their rightful places, you’ll earn the Lost and Found Achievement. This Achievement also awards you with the Sandy Quotidian Wear Ensemble, modeled above by my orc. How dashing!

While you’re exploring Khaz Algar, don’t forget to pick up the free 34-slot bag from the Kaja’Cola Vending Machine in the Ringing Deeps. In case you missed Lionel, there’s also a talking fish in the Isle of Dorn that grants a free battle pet.