The Tall Tales in Sea of Thieves is one of my favorite features to play, especially with friends. But what makes it truly worthwhile, is collecting the rewards that come with them.
Table of contents
All rewards for Tall Tales in Sea of Thieves
You will earn cosmetic rewards when completing commendations when playing Tall Tales in Sea of Thieves.
Note that some of these commendations will require you to play the same Tall Tales a few times.
| Tall Tale | Reward | How to earn reward |
| Maiden Voyage | Pirate Lord’s Jacket | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Magpie’s Fortune Sails | Complete all Maiden Voyage Commendations | |
| The Journey to Melee Island | Legend of Monkey Island Figurines | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Tavern Chef’s Uniform | Complete the Tall Tale | |
| ‘Melee by Moonlight’ | Complete all The Journey to Melee Island Commendations | |
| The Quest for Guybrush | Idol o’ Many Hands | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Circus Superstar Costume | Complete the Tall Tale | |
| Governor Guybrush Portrait | Complete all The Quest for Guybrush Commendations | |
| The Lair of LeChuck | Burning Blade Cutlass | Complete the Tall Tale |
|
| ||
| The Legend of Monkey Island Cutlass | Complete the Tall Tale | |
| LeChuck Portrait | Complete all The Lair of LeChuck Commendations | |
| Mighty Pirate Title | Complete all The Lair of LeChuck Commendations | |
| Monkey Island Shanty | Complete all The Lair of LeChuck Commendations | |
| A Pirate’s Life | Cursed Captain’s Hat | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Cursed Captain’s Sails | Complete all A Pirate’s Life Commendations | |
| The Sunken Pearl | Revenge of the Silver Blade Cutlass | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Revenge of the Silver Blade Capstan | Complete all The Sunken Pearl Commendations | |
| Captains of the Damned | Tankard of the Damned | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Concertina of the Damned | Complete all Captains of the Damned Commendations | |
|
| ||
| Hurdy-Gurdy of the Damned | Complete all Captains of the Damned Commendations | |
| Banjo of the Damned | Complete all Captains of the Damned Commendations | |
| Drum of the Damned | Complete all Captains of the Damned Commendations | |
| Dark Brethren | Pistol of the Sunken Sorrow | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Figurehead of the Sunken Sorrow | Complete all Dark Brethren Commendations | |
| Lords of the Sea | Cannons of Sunken Sorrow | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Hull of Sunken Sorrow | Complete all Lords of the Sea Commendations | |
| Yo Ho (A Pirate’s Life) Shanty | Complete all Commendations for all five A Pirate’s Life Tall Tales | |
| The Shroud Breaker | Pirate’s Lord Hat | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Magpie’s Wing Cannons | Complete all The Shroud Breaker Commendations | |
|
| ||
| The Cursed Rogue | Briggsy’s Sword | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Order of Souls Eye Curse | Complete all The Cursed Rogue Commendations | |
| The Legendary Storyteller | Briggsy’s Hat | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Briggsy’s Sails | Complete all The Legendary Storyteller Commendations | |
| Stars of a Thief | Constellation Tattoo Set | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Ancient Spyglass | Complete all Stars of a Thief Commendations | |
| Wild Rose | Rose’s Compass | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Wild Rose Wheel | Complete all Wild Rose Commendations | |
| Art of the Trickster | Rum Bottle Spyglass | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Trapmaker’s Capstan | Complete all Art of the Trickster Commendations | |
|
| ||
| The Fate of the Morningstar | Morningstar Flag | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Morningstar Sails | Complete all The Fate of the Morningstar Commendations | |
| Revenge of the Morningstar | Morningstar Hull | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Morningstar Figurehead | Complete all Revenge of the Morningstar Commendations | |
| Shores of Gold | Gold Hoarder Jacket | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Gold Hoarder Figurehead | Complete all Shores of Gold Commendations | |
| Shores of Gold Curse | Complete all Commendations for all nine Shores of Gold Tall Tales | |
| The Seabound Soul | Pendragon’s Sword of Souls | Complete the Tall Tale |
| Ashen Dragon Sails | Complete all The Seabound Soul Commendations | |
| Heart of Fire | Ashen Dragon Hull | Complete the Tall Tale |
| The Ashen Curse | Complete all Heart of Fire Commendations | |
As you can see, there are some incredibly unique prizes for those who go after all the commendations, although there are some sweet rewards for players who just complete each Tall Tale once.
Now you’ve seen all the prizes, it’ll be worth going over how to begin each quest.
How to start all Tall Tales in Sea of Thieves
There are 20 Tall Tales currently in the Sea of Thieves, each separated into their own storylines. This means that (for the most part) you can’t just begin any Tall Tale, you must start with the first of each storyline and advance in order. When diving you’ll be brought right to the island where you can begin the Tall Tale.
Like usual voyages, players will have to vote for the Tall Tale to begin.
Maiden Voyage
The Maiden Voyage is a tutorial for the Sea of Thieves, although players will have to manually select to play it. This can be done in the main menu.
Upon clicking “play,” players will be presented with choices. From here, you can jump straight into the Maiden Voyage. Make sure to collect all the commendations whilst you’re there!
Shroudbreaker Tall Tales
The Shroudbreaker Tall Tales are my personal favorite, and were the first Tall Tales to be added to the game. Note that upon finishing The Cursed Rogue, the subsequent four Tall Tales are unlocked, but those four need to be completed (in any order) to unlock The Fate of the Morningstar.
| Tall Tale | How to start |
| The Shroudbreaker | Vote for the Tall Tale next to the Mysterious Stranger in any of the Taverns in any of the Outposts |
| The Cursed Rogue | Vote for the Tall Tale in the Order of Souls tent in Plunder Outpost |
| The Legendary Storyteller | Vote for the Tall Tale by Tasha in the Tavern of Ancient Spire Outpost |
| Stars of a Thief | Vote for the Tall Tale by Sudds in The North Star Seapost |
| Wildrose | Vote for the Tall Tale in the Order of Souls tent in Sanctuary Outpost |
| The Art of the Trickster | Vote for the Tall Tale by Salty in Plunder Valley, by the shipwreck on the eastern shore |
| The Fate of the Morningstar | Vote for the Tall Tale by the Ferryman on the Ferry of the Damned |
| Revenge of the Morningstar | Vote for the Tall Tale by Sandra at the Shipwright Shop on Dagger Tooth Outpost |
| Shores of Gold | Vote for the Tall Tale by Grace Morrow outside the Tavern in Morrow’s Peak Outpost |
The Ashen Age Tall Tales
The Fireheart Tall Tales was the second set of Tall Tales to be added to Sea of Thieves, preparing the world for Captain Flameheart. You can play these Tall Tales in any order.
| Tall Tale | How to start |
| The Seabound Soul | Vote for the Tall Tale inside the Captain’s Quarters in the Blackwyche shipwreck at Shipwreck Bay Outpost |
| Heart of Fire | Vote for the Tall Tale by Tallulah in the Tavern of Morrow’s Peak Outpost |
A Pirate’s Life Tall Tales
These Tall Tales are a crossover between Sea of Thieves and The Pirates of the Caribbean. Yes, they’re awesome.
| Tall Tale | How to start |
| A Pirate’s Life | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Castaway’s Camp in any of the Outposts. |
| The Sunken Pearl | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Castaway’s Camp in any of the Outposts. |
| Captains of the Damned | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Castaway’s Camp in any of the Outposts. |
| Dark Brethren | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Castaway’s Camp in any of the Outposts. |
| Lords of the Sea | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Castaway’s Camp in any of the Outposts. |
Monkey Island Tall Tales
These Tall Tales are a crossover between Sea of Thieves and Treasure Island and has a very colorful cast of characters. You can play these Tall Tales in any order.
| Tall Tale | How to start |
| The Journey to Melee Island | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Capsize Charter’s tent in any of the Outposts. |
| The Quest for Guybrush | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Capsize Charter’s tent in any of the Outposts. |
| The Lair of LeChuck | Vote for the Tall Tale at the Capsize Charter’s tent in any of the Outposts. |
Equipped with the knowledge of all rewards of the Tall Tales in Sea of Thieves, and how to start them, you can embark on some truly incredible voyages. Good luck!
Published: Apr 30, 2024 11:24 am